New System Install As Low As $60/month & Same-Day Free In-Home Estimates! Read More

Skip navigation

Menu

Heating

Should I Get a Heat Pump or a Furnace?

Home | Blog | Published on October 23rd, 2023
person-holding-chin-with-wondering-expression-on-face

As the weather starts to turn chilly, it’s time to figure out how you’re going to stay warm this winter. If your heating system isn’t up to snuff anymore, what are you going to replace it with? Heat pumps and furnaces each have their own benefits. Which is right for you? Heat pumps and furnaces each have their own benefits. One major benefit of heat pump systems is their energy efficiency and ability to provide both heating and cooling, making them a versatile choice for many houses. Which is right for you? Take the time to consider some details so you can decide for yourself.

Furnaces

Most furnaces use either electricity or natural gas to create heat. Electric furnaces are extremely efficient, turning virtually all of the energy they consume into heat, but electricity is a more expensive fuel source. Electric furnaces themselves also tend to be somewhat more expensive than gas furnaces. However, they do last longer, provided they receive annual maintenance.

Gas furnaces last, on average, 10-15 years, and electric furnaces have been known to last for longer. While they are slightly less efficient in terms of what percentage of the energy they use that becomes heat, they are more economically efficient, both because of their lower initial cost and the lower cost of natural gas as a fuel source.

If you’ve had one type of furnace before, and are considering switching because the other sounds more appealing, there are some additional hurdles and potential costs to the process of furnace replacement in Shelby County, AL. Switching from gas to electric is fairly straightforward and will generally only require some minor modifications such as to your venting system. During this process, replacement parts may be needed to ensure compatibility and proper function.

If you’ve never had a gas furnace before, you’ll need to make sure a natural gas connection is available from your utility company. It may be, whether because of a gas furnace a previous homeowner had or because of gas lines for the stove, water heater, or clothes dryer. If not, evaluate the cost of having the utility company connect you before making your decision. Certain replacements may also be required if the existing infrastructure is outdated.

Heat Pumps

As we said, furnaces use energy to create heat. This is a very energy-intensive process. Heat pumps do not generate heat, they simply transfer it, carrying warmth from one place to another. The outdoor unit and indoor unit of a heat pump work together to transfer heat efficiently between the inside and outside of your home. This makes them the most energy-efficient heating system that currently exists. 

While homes in colder climates require some sort of additional heat source beyond a heat pump, that’s not the case in areas where temperatures rarely dip below freezing. Even when it’s colder outdoors than in, heat pumps can provide warmth because they rely on the temperature differential between the air and the super-cooled refrigerant, not on the air being warm. However, heat pump efficiency can decrease in cold weather, and some systems may require more energy to maintain comfort.

Heat pumps are also a cooling system. Simply switch the direction of refrigerant flow and your heater becomes an air conditioner. The reversing valve is responsible for switching between heating and cooling modes by changing the direction of refrigerant flow based on the thermostat setting. When the system is set to heating mode, the heat pump efficiently provides warmth during colder months, which is crucial for maintaining indoor comfort and system efficiency. This makes them a perfect choice if you’re also concerned that your air conditioner is aging or failing, especially since they can run for twenty years compared to the 10-15 years of a typical AC unit.

Finally, heat pumps can operate using ductwork or they can use a ductless system. If your ducts are deteriorating or have been damaged, they can be eliminated altogether, saving you from massive energy waste. However, ductless system installation is an additional expense that should be assessed before you make your choice. Technicians can provide guidance on installation and maintenance as part of comprehensive heat pump services. Many HVAC companies also offer plumbing services, providing repairs and installations to address urgent plumbing issues as part of their overall home comfort solutions. Today’s heat pumps are more efficient and eligible for various federal and state rebates.

Consulting with a professional is the only way to get tailored recommendations based on your home and your specific needs. 
Reputable companies provide upfront pricing for heat pump replacement and installation services, ensuring transparency and no hidden fees.

Regular heat pump service is essential for maintaining system efficiency and reliability. It’s important to schedule heat pump repair promptly if you notice issues such as a refrigerant leak, loose parts, or thermostat issues, as heat pump repair costs can vary depending on the problem. Signs that a heat pump may need repairs include thermostat issues, fan issues, belt issues, and parts issues. A qualified heat pump repair service can diagnose and fix problems, whether it’s repairing or replacing components, and ensure your heat pump is properly repaired. If your current system is beyond repair, a technician may recommend installing a new unit to restore comfort and efficiency. Having your heat pump serviced regularly by experienced technicians helps prevent breakdowns and extends the life of your HVAC system. Regular maintenance and prompt heat pump repairs are key to optimal performance and energy savings.

Maintenance and Repair

Keeping your heat pump system in top shape is key to enjoying a comfortable and energy-efficient home year-round. Regular heat pump maintenance not only helps your equipment run more efficiently, but it also reduces energy costs and prevents common heat pump issues that can lead to expensive repairs down the line. Maintenance services typically include cleaning or replacing air filters, inspecting the compressor, checking electrical components, and making sure all moving parts are clean and well-lubricated. Every major equipment manufacturer includes a requirement for regular maintenance as a provision of their warranty coverage.

It’s a good idea to schedule heat pump maintenance at least twice a year once before the heating season and again before the cooling season. This routine care helps catch minor issues early, so they don’t turn into bigger, more costly problems that could disrupt your comfort. By investing in regular maintenance, you’ll help your heat pump system deliver reliable heating and cooling, extend the life of your equipment, and keep your home comfortable no matter the season. Plus, a well-maintained system uses less energy, saving you more money on your utility bills over time. Signs that indicate it may be time for heat pump replacement include frequent repairs and decreased performance.

Common Issues and Costs

Even though heat pumps are known for being energy efficient and reliable, they can still develop problems over time especially if regular maintenance is overlooked. In the Birmingham, AL area, homeowners may encounter a range of common heat pump issues that can impact comfort, efficiency, and energy costs. Addressing these problems quickly with the help of a professional heat pump repair service is essential to keep your system running smoothly and your home comfortable.

Some of the most common heat pump problems include:

  • Thermostat issues: If your thermostat isn’t working properly, your heat pump system may not maintain the desired temperature, leading to discomfort and higher energy costs. Repair costs for thermostat issues typically range from $100 to $500.
  • Refrigerant leaks: Low refrigerant levels can reduce efficiency and prevent your heat pump from heating or cooling effectively. Fixing refrigerant leaks can cost between $200 and $1,000, depending on the extent of the leak and the need for replacement parts.
  • Compressor failures: The compressor is a vital component of your heat pump. If it fails, your system may stop working entirely. Compressor repairs or replacements can range from $500 to $2,000.
  • Blower motor replacements: A malfunctioning blower motor can reduce airflow and make it harder to keep your home warm or cool. Replacing a blower motor usually costs between $200 and $500.
  • Electrical component repairs: Issues with electrical components can cause your heat pump to stop working or operate inefficiently. Repairing electrical components typically costs $100 to $500.

Heat pump repair costs can vary depending on the specific problem, the age and condition of your system, and the price of replacement parts. Regular maintenance services such as cleaning or replacing air filters, inspecting electrical components, and checking refrigerant levels can help prevent many of these issues and keep your heat pump system energy efficient.

If you notice any signs of trouble, such as unusual noises, reduced heating or cooling, or higher energy bills, it’s important to schedule heat pump repair as soon as possible. Prompt repairs can prevent minor issues from turning into major, costly problems. In the Birmingham area, AL heat pump repair services are available around the clock to handle both emergency repairs and routine maintenance.

By investing in regular maintenance and addressing heat pump problems quickly, you can extend the lifespan of your system, improve efficiency, and save money on repair costs. Keeping your heat pump serviced by experienced technicians ensures your home stays comfortable and energy efficient all year long.

Making the Right Choice: Heat Pump vs. Furnace

Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace comes down to your home’s needs, your local climate, and your long-term goals for energy efficiency and savings. Heat pumps are especially energy efficient in mild climates, offering both heating and cooling from a single system. They work by transferring heat energy using refrigerant flow, which means they can cool your home in the summer and keep it warm in the winter all with one piece of equipment. This dual functionality can help you save on both installation and energy costs, as you won’t need separate systems for heating and cooling.

Furnaces, on the other hand, generate heat through combustion and are often better suited for areas with colder winters. While the upfront cost of a heat pump system can be higher than a furnace, the long-term savings on energy bills and the convenience of a single system for both heating and cooling can make it a smart investment. When making your decision, consider your local energy costs, climate, and personal preferences. Consulting with a professional technician can help you weigh the benefits and drawbacks of each option, ensuring you make an informed decision that’s right for your home and budget.

Conclusion and Next Steps

In summary, heat pumps offer a reliable, energy-efficient solution for both heating and cooling, helping homeowners save money and enjoy year-round comfort with a single system. Regular maintenance is essential to keep your heat pump system running smoothly, reduce energy costs, and extend the life of your equipment. Understanding how a heat pump works, the importance of routine care, and the key factors in choosing between a heat pump and a furnace will empower you to make the best choice for your home.

If you’re experiencing heat pump problems, considering a new heat pump installation, or simply want to keep your current heat pump system in peak condition, don’t hesitate to reach out to a professional technician. Whether you need pump repair, heat pump maintenance, or expert advice on your next steps, scheduling service now can help you avoid costly repairs and ensure your home stays comfortable and energy efficient. Heat pump replacement can improve energy efficiency and lower utility bills compared to older models. Take action today to enjoy the many benefits of a well-maintained heat pump system saving money, reducing your environmental impact, and keeping your home comfortable for years to come.

“Your experience is what matters most!” Contact Douglas Cooling & Heating today for help with all your heating needs.

Douglas is Dedicated to Exceptional Customer Service

Review Stars
Douglas Cooling Heating Plumbing Electrical BBB A+ Logo

They are always kind, respectful, friendly and thoughtful. I'm impressed and grateful!

- Valued Customer

Serving the Greater Birmingham Area Since 1972

Douglas Cooling Heating Plumbing Electrical Spanner